Does Using Technology in the
Classroom Help College Students?
Almost anywhere in the world, you are likely to find people doing the
same thing at eateries and in other public places, on trains and buses
or wherever else you look.
More and more people spend their day looking at laptop computers,
smartphones or other personal electronic devices. They are thinking
mainly about their electronic devices, and not much else.
The same can be said about the world of higher education. More and more
college students have no problem walking into a classroom and
immediately opening their laptops. Others may spend an entire study
period with a smartphone in hand.
Some people argue that the increasing use of technology can have many
helpful effects on society. But recent research suggests that using
technology during class time may harm college students’ ability to
remember and process the subject material they are learning.
Arnold Glass is a professor in the School of Arts and Sciences at
Rutgers University in New Brunswick, New Jersey. Glass and a student
researcher investigated the issue of divided student attention. They
reported their findings in July 2018 in the publication Educational
Psychology.
The study involved 118 Rutgers students who were taking the same upper
level college class in psychology.
The students were permitted to use any electronic device as much as they
wanted during half of their daily class periods. During the other half,
researchers closely watched them to make sure no one was using any
technology.
The students’ academic performance was measured in several ways
throughout the semester. The students took a short test every day,
longer tests every few weeks and a final exam covering all the class
material.
The researchers found that the average daily quiz results showed no
evidence of harmful effects from the use of technology. However, the
average results of the larger tests and final exam told a different
story. They showed that all the students performed poorly on questions
covering material taught on days when they were permitted to use
technology in the classroom.
It did not matter whether or not the students reported that they had
actually used a laptop or cellphone on those days.
This is by no means the first or largest study to look at this issue.
Still, Glass argues that it shows the use of electronic devices in the
classroom prevents students from processing information. The students
hear what the professor is saying. But they might be buying things
online or reading unrelated emails at the same time, for example. So
they are not thinking deeply about the subject matter as they are
hearing it.
And that, Glass says, makes it harder for the information to enter their
long term memory.
“Even though a few minutes later they know what the professor said, a
week later if you ask them, all they remember is that they were in class
a week ago,” he told VOA. “They no longer remember what the professor
said because they eliminated the opportunity.”
University of Michigan professor Kentaro Toyama says he has seen this
problem progressing for years now. Toyama teaches classes on information
technology at the university’s School of Information. So it was no
surprise to him when many students started bringing laptops to his
classes about 10 years ago.
At first, Toyama thought it was a good idea as it could help students in
their note keeping, or could quickly provide information during class
discussions. But then he started noticing troubling behavior.
“Students would be looking at their laptop and they would suddenly
smile, and it wasn’t because … there was anything funny happening in the
class,” Toyama noted. “What I realized very quickly was … these students
… were on social media … and that’s what they were smiling about. And
over time, as … this increased, I just felt like I no longer had the
attention of my students.”
At that point, Toyama decided to bar students from bringing laptops to
his classes. Yet it was not a total ban. His classes often include
activities that involve working with technology. So he says he only bans
laptops during the lecture part of his classes, where he needs students’
full attention.
Toyama says the ban is partial because he feels that technology can
intensify both good and bad qualities in anyone. He notes that
professors can make classes more interesting by using technology to
present information in different ways. And there are many students who
can listen, process information and investigate something online to add
to discussions all at the same time.
But even if technology is helpful to some students, there are times when
it needs to be turned off, as it may harm others, he notes. In 2013,
researchers at two Canadian universities reported that laptops not only
harmed the academic performance of users. Students without computers
were also distracted and, as a result, suffered academically.
However, Lauren Margulieux argues that even Toyama’s relatively balanced
way of dealing with technology represents a limited understanding of the
issue.
Margulieux is an assistant professor of learning sciences at Georgia
State University in Atlanta. She says there are times in which classroom
use of technology is completely unavoidable, as with students with
disabilities. And in the current job market, students need to be able to
develop the skills that will make their divided attention not only
possible but successful.
For example, at many modern business meetings, people might be talking,
listening and operating a device all at the same time.
So, Margulieux says, educators need to think about preparing their
students to enter this quickly changing workforce. And in doing so, they
may have to consider that something other than technology is distracting
students. Traditional methods of teaching, such as a professor standing
and talking in front of a class for an hour, may not be as interesting
to today’s college students.
In fact, the University of Michigan’s Center for Research on Teaching
and Learning has created a special software program, called Lecture
Tools. Students can use the program on their personal devices during a
given class. It lets them inform the professor of how well they are
understanding the course material.
“Designing instruction in a way that gets students to engage with that
material more would be a better solution than to ban laptops, because
technology, in general, is not the only way that students find to
distract themselves in class,” said Margulieux.
She and Toyama agree that one other way of solving the problem may be
technology itself. Special software already exists for online teaching
and testing programs. It can be used to observe student activity on a
given electronic device and prevent them from opening unrelated pages
and programs.
At the start of this school year, Purdue University in Indiana announced
it would be using similar software in several of its lecture halls. This
aims to prevent students from distracting themselves by blocking video
services like Netflix. |